Introduction: Questions Are the Key
The difference between catching a liar and being misled often comes down to the quality of the questions asked. In interviews — whether investigative or recruitment — poorly framed questions give liars room to hide. Strategic questions, however, create pressure points where deception cracks.
Why Good Liars Fear Good Questions
Liars rely on rehearsed stories and generalisations. A well-placed, unexpected question disrupts that preparation, forcing them into improvisation. Cognitive psychology shows that lies collapse when liars are asked to provide:
-
Sensory detail (sights, sounds, smells).
-
Chronological recall (events in reverse order).
-
Emotional perspective (how they felt in the moment).
The 4 Types of Questions That Reveal Deception
1. Open-Ended Questions
These encourage expansive answers that reveal contradictions.
-
Recruitment example: “Tell me about the most challenging project you managed from start to finish.”
-
Investigative example: “Walk me through everything you did between 5 p.m. and 9 p.m. that evening.”
Why it works: Liars prefer closed questions because “yes/no” limits exposure. Open-ended questions force them to build detail — a difficult task when fabricating.
2. Unexpected Questions
Liars rehearse predictable questions. Throwing in unusual ones disrupts the script.
-
Recruitment: “Who was the most difficult person you worked with, and how did you resolve it?”
-
Investigative: “What could your neighbour confirm about your whereabouts?”
Why it works: Deceptive people often falter when required to provide fresh detail outside their rehearsed narrative.
3. Reverse-Order Questions
Memory is chronological. Asking people to recount events in reverse order increases cognitive load.
-
“Tell me what happened after the meeting, and then go backwards step by step until you arrived at the office that morning.”
Why it works: Truthful memories can be mentally rewound. Lies, being constructed, often lack this flexible structure.
4. Detail Probes
Focus on sensory or incidental detail:
-
“What colour was the carpet in the office?”
-
“What did you smell when you entered the building?”
Why it works: Truthful memories naturally include incidental details. Liars rarely embed these convincingly.
Case Study: Recruitment Interview
A candidate claimed to have worked on a major advertising campaign. When asked, “Who was the client’s marketing director at the time?” he hesitated. Later, asked to recall the campaign in reverse order, his story broke down. This exposed exaggeration.
Case Study: Criminal Investigation
In a theft case, the suspect gave a confident alibi. Investigators asked, “What did the air smell like in the bar when you arrived?” He faltered, unable to answer. Later evidence showed he was never there.
Best Practices for Questioning
-
Mix question types – Don’t rely on one strategy.
-
Revisit key points – Ask again later to test consistency.
-
Watch for contradictions – Across words, tone, and body language.
-
Allow silence – Don’t rescue them; let the discomfort speak.
Conclusion: The Power of Strategic Questions
Good questioning is the interviewer’s superpower. It strips away the safety net of rehearsed stories and exposes the truth hidden beneath.
At LieDetectorOnline.com, we train professionals to use evidence-based questioning strategies that reveal deception before it costs organisations time, money, or justice.